It is possible to filter the output of the modules and even the JReviews Custom List menu by adding a CUSTOM WHERE statement that looks like this:
(Listing.id IN (SELECT DISTINCT listing_id FROM #__jreviews_paid_orders WHERE order_active = 1 AND plan_id = 5))
If you want to match multiple plans the statement can be written like this:
(Listing.id IN (SELECT DISTINCT listing_id FROM #__jreviews_paid_orders WHERE order_active = 1 AND plan_id IN (4,5,6)))
Make sure you change the plan_id(s) to match the ids of your paid plans.